Denny, thanks for your treatise; it was fascinating. Where is a good place to
get such wheelsets in an ecconomic fashion? I have close to 1,000 pieces of
equipment that could benefit from such conversions. Also, does Reboxx make a
wheel tire that has a prototypical profile?
Thanks again!
Val
Denny Anspach wrote:
> The good Rev. Harding makes a very good case for truck improvements
> by replacing wheel sets. He is on a good straight and narrow path.
> Although initially taking his same exact footsteps over the last
> several years, I have in the interim changed directions slightly,
> however. I now custom fit each and every new car, or any car that
> arrives on the rip track with new Reboxx .088" wheels. The
> improvement in rollability has been an absolute revolution; and the
> results a revelation.
>
> To measure improvement, I use a "roll tester" purchased from Reboxx,
> a 2' stretch of track that describes a "dip" about 4" high on the
> ends and 1" in the middle, the track actually following the segment
> of a circle. One takes a truck and allows it free to roll, and you
> count how many times it rolls back and forth, counting every single
> movement, no matter how miniscule. You do this three times to five to
> average out errors. Then you remove the old wheel sets and measure
> the axle length. On most trucks, I also then take the "Tool",
> actually a cutting bit, and "clean out" the journal holes.
>
> Then you trial fit in the new Reboxx wheelsets, using the measured
> length of the original axle as a starter. Reboxx wheels come in axle
> lengths of .005" segments from 0.950 to 1.055". I keep a full supply
> from about 1.00 to 1.050, concentrating on 1.015 to 1.040. As a try
> these out, I measure them on the roll tester, keeping a note book of
> results. Because NONE of these trucks, plastic, cast metal- old or
> new-, or (and especially) brass are precision instruments in any
> fashion, it is not at all unusual that a given truck will roll best
> with axles of differing lengths.
>
> Inasmuch as I model only steam/transition era, all my tests have been
> on older prototypes.
>
> Notes:
>
> 1) Kadee metal "Bettendorf" improve on the average 75-95% by
> replacing the kadee 1.015" wheels with Reboxx 1.020" wheels (10 rolls
> vs. 17-19).
>
> 2) Athearn metal sprung trucks will improve "most" of the time, but
> not significantly (3-4 rolls with Jay Bee 1.015 wheels vs. 7-8 with
> Reboxx 1.045"). Except for "historical" purposes, I now retire all of
> these trucks.
>
> 3) Silver Streak metal trucks: Original metal wheels 5, Reboxx 1.045" 12.
>
> 4) Lindberg plastic sprung (famous for "free rolling"): original
> plastic wheels 3, Reboxx 1.015 23!
>
> 5) Kadee Bettendorf T: 15 original, 20 1.020 Reboxx.
>
> 5) Central Valley metal sprung: 4 original, 14 1.020.
>
> 6) Trans Canada plastic AAR: original 5, Reboxx 1.020 19.
>
> 7) Similar spectacular improvements have occurred with a variety of
> passenger trucks, most of them Central Valley, but also with the most
> current Walthers.
>
> IN any given truck, the above results may be only a guide, because
> there can be such individual variability.
>
> Placing tiny drops of oil in the journals has been a "no-no" since
> Linn Westcott so decreed a generation ago. Well, although I think
> that he was correct, and remains so in most instances in this regard,
> I have on occasion had even more spectacular improvement at times
> when oil is present.
>
> I have now converted over 100 cars, and have been marketing to others
> boxes of removed metal Kadee and Jay Bee wheel sets. The sheer
> palpable improvement in rollability translates directly into the
> increased ease with which any given locomotive can handle heavier or
> long trains over your rolling and curving profiles.
>
> Keep in mind that these wheels will help only in those trucks with
> tapered journals. In trucks with straight journals, i.e. a lot of
> brass, the only salvation currently are the ball bearinged wheels
> from Intermountain and/or PSC. I am experimenting with experimental
> coned bearing inserts in several of these trucks so that the standard
> Reboxx wheels might be fitted. No results to report as yet, however.
>
> Denny
>
> If you are doubtful about the .088" wheel tread width, be reassured.
> They will track repeatedly and faithfully through the most
> complicated "dog's breakfast" variety of NMRA-standard trackwork
> without a single hitch, and they have been doing so now for some
> time. And best of all, they simply look great (they make the common
> .110" wheels that we have used for 75 years look "positively
> porcine"- quoting Tony Thompson).
>
>
>
>
>
>
--
The only time we have had lasting peace is after a Military victory.
_________________________________________________
/( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (\
|=======================================================|
|================= S A N T A F E ==================|
|[_] == == [_] [_] [=]|
|| |___==_==___======[_] [_] [_] [_]======_______500____|
||_|/'( )==( )'\_________________________/'( )==( )'\___|
------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~-->
Buy Ink Cartridges or Refill Kits for your HP, Epson, Canon or Lexmark
Printer at MyInks.com. Free s/h on orders $50 or more to the US & Canada.
http://www.c1tracking.com/l.asp?cid=5511
http://us.click.yahoo.com/mOAaAA/3exGAA/qnsNAA/8ZCslB/TM
---------------------------------------------------------------------~->
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
|