BRHSLIST
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [BRHSlist] Steam in Twin Cities

To: <BRHSlist@yahoogroups.com>
Subject: Re: [BRHSlist] Steam in Twin Cities
From: "Marshall Thayer" <zephyr9903@e...>
Date: Mon, 30 Sep 2002 13:26:41 -0700
References: <ana9mb+ju5p@e...>
>> Researching for a model with a Twin Cities setting (I want to run 
Rock Island and GN as well). What CB&Q steam locomotives 
would be appropriate for a mid- to late-1940's era? <<


You've picked an era of flux, since diesels were coming on property thick and 
fast after 1946. Please bear in mind that the answers I will give here are 
general rather than specific, but if you refine your date a little closer 
and/or someone has local assignment sheets, you may get specific answers.

At the beginning of your window, steam power will be varied. With the exception 
of the Twin Cities Zephyrs, your passenger trains will be powered by Pacifics, 
Hudsons or (on the transcontinentals) O-5 Northerns. Heavy freights will be 
handled by O-5s, with any of the Mikes (except O-4s all assigned to Lines West 
and oil burning by this time). Way freights will be Mikes or possibly an R-4 or 
R-5 Prairie. Since the Twin Cities had no Q branch lines, none of your smaller 
road power (ten wheelers or Atlantics) will be in evidence. For switching, 
you'd still have some steam . . . this is probably a good place for the P2K 
USRA 0-6-0 as a G-5. One of the ex-Prairie 0-6-0s was imported quite a while 
back - if you can find one, it would be appropriate.

At the end of your window, things have changed quite a bit. By 1950, the 
occasional freight might have an 0-5 or a Mike, and way freights would probably 
have Mikes as well. There were enough passenger diesels by 1950 that they had 
even taken over most suburban service, so the only passenger steam you are 
likely to see is the occasional S-4 Hudson. Although a single G-8 0-6-0 was 
maintained in the TC area as late as 1952, it would mostly be in standby, as 
post war switchers had taken over the majority of yard duties.

You've named the five-year span that saw the fastest change in motive power on 
the Burlington. If you want steam only as a scenic token, I'd suggest moving 
toward the end of your selected period. If you like it a lot, the closer you 
are to V-J Day the better . . .

Marshall Thayer








[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>