Re: [CBQ] ChatGPT Output for Bronze Green and Indian Red for Structures

["Nelson Moyer via groups.io" <npmoyer=hotmail.com@groups.io>]

Dave,

 

I used your recommendation for the only Q depot Iâ??ve painted thus far, and entered it in a NMRA Regional Contest. A well known modeler told me it was the closest colors to the Q originals he had seen. Thought Iâ??d pass that complement on to you, since itâ??s your recommendation.

 

That said, ModelFlex isnâ??t my favorite paint, so Iâ??ll try the Vallejo options to see how they compare with ModelFlex on my next depot.

 

Nelson

 

From: CBQ@groups.io <CBQ@groups.io> On Behalf Of Dave Lotz via groups.io
Sent: Thursday, July 16, 2026 1:46 PM
To: CBQ@groups.io
Subject: Re: [CBQ] ChatGPT Output for Bronze Green and Indian Red for Structures

 

Ricky,

 

For the Bronze Green in ModelFlex, I recommend their 16-100 European Dark Green.

For the Indian Red in ModelFlex I recommend their 16-15 Maroon Tuscan Oxide Red.

Thatâ??s what Iâ??ve used on all my CB&Q structures.

 

Dave

 

From: CBQ@groups.io <CBQ@groups.io> On Behalf Of Rick Keil via groups.io
Sent: Thursday, July 16, 2026 2:26 PM
To: CBQ IO Group <cbq@groups.io>
Subject: [CBQ] ChatGPT Output for Bronze Green and Indian Red for Structures

 

All,

 

Below is my question input and the output from ChatGPT for matching the CB&Q Bronze Green and Indian Red used on CB&Q structures.  I would like to thank Nelson Moyer for the paint chips and additional information he provided for the input.

 

I want to caution the group.  This is just one output from one AI tool.  Other tools may provide different outputs.  Additionally, these have not been checked against photographs or recollections of people with better knowledge of the CB&Q than.

 

Finally, I have been using ChatGPT as a starting point since I am red/green colorblind.  I will be using some of these and having my wife provide the better eyeballs to see if they are close to pictures or other factory painted models.

 

Please provide feedback.

 

I will run other colors as well and I plan to make they outputs available to the BRHS website for future reference.

 

****OUTPUT******

 

The structure paint chips published in The Zephyr are among the best surviving references for CB&Q structure colors, but they have one significant limitation for modelers: they represent full-scale colors viewed under normal lighting. When those same colors are applied to HO, N, or even O scale models, they generally appear too dark, especially the Bronze Green. The Indian Red also tends to benefit from a slight increase in chroma (saturation) while remaining a deep oxide red.

This follows the same "scale effect" used by military and aircraft modelers. For structures, I generally recommend:

• Bronze Green: lighten approximately 10â??15%
• Indian Red: lighten about 5â??10% while slightly increasing saturation

That produces a model that looks much closer to a prototype viewed outdoors.

Recommended Target Colors

CB&Q Bronze Green (Model Appearance)

Target appearance:

• Deep green-black
• Slight olive cast
• Noticeably lighter than Pullman Green
• Approximately between FS 34052 and FS 34079 after scale effect

CB&Q Indian Red (Model Appearance)

Target appearance:

• Warm oxide red
• Slightly brighter than brick red
• Less brown than Tuscan
• Similar to fresh iron oxide paint

---

Recommended Paints

Brand	Bronze Green	Indian Red
Tamiya	XF-70 Dark Green 2 (lightened)	XF-9 Hull Red + XF-7 Red
Mr. Color	C302 Green FS34092 + white	C41 Red Brown + C3 Red
Tru-Color (formerly Tru-Scale equivalent)	Pullman Green lightened	Oxide Red lightened
AK Interactive	RC292 Bronze Green or RC028 Dark Green	RC015 Oxide Red
Mission Models	MMP-095 Olive Drab base	MMP-104 Oxide Red
Micro-Mark	Pullman Green lightened	Oxide Red
Vallejo Model Air / Model Color	71.016 US Dark Green or 70.893 US Dark Green	70.982 Cavalry Brown
Badger Modelflex	Pullman Green	Oxide Red

---

Mixing Formulas

Tamiya

Bronze Green

A very convincing CB&Q structure color is:

• 5 parts XF-70 Dark Green 2
• 1 part XF-5 Green
• 1 part XF-2 White

Alternative:

• 4 XF-11 J.N. Green
• 2 XF-62 Olive Drab
• 1 XF-2 White

This gives the slight olive cast visible on restored depots.

---

Indian Red

• 5 XF-9 Hull Red
• 2 XF-7 Flat Red
• 1 XF-64 Red Brown

If weathered:

Add approximately 5% XF-57 Buff.

---

Mr. Color

Bronze Green

• 5 C302 Green FS34092
• 1 C303 Green FS34102
• 1 C1 White

or

• 6 C304 Olive Drab
• 2 C302
• 1 White

---

Indian Red

• 5 C41 Red Brown
• 2 C3 Red
• 1 C44 Tan

Produces a very convincing oxide mineral paint.

---

Tru-Color (successor to Tru-Scale)

Because Tru-Color does not offer an exact CB&Q structure color:

Bronze Green

• 85% Pullman Green
• 15% White

Indian Red

• 80% Oxide Red
• 20% Boxcar Red

---

AK Interactive Real Colors

Bronze Green

• 6 RC292 Bronze Green
• 1 RC004 White

or

• 5 RC028 Dark Green
• 1 RC024 Olive Drab
• 1 White

---

Indian Red

• 5 RC015 Oxide Red
• 1 RC002 Red
• ½ RC004 White

---

Mission Models

Bronze Green

• 5 MMP Olive Drab
• 1 MMP Green
• 1 MMP White

---

Indian Red

• 5 MMP Oxide Red
• 1 MMP Signal Red
• ½ MMP White

---

Micro-Mark

Micro-Mark's railroad colors generally follow older Floquil shades.

Bronze Green

• Pullman Green
• Lighten approximately 15% with White

---

Indian Red

• Oxide Red
• Add 10% Boxcar Red

---

Vallejo

Vallejo offers some of the closest matches without much mixing.

Bronze Green

Best choice:

• 6 parts 70.893 US Dark Green
• 1 part 70.924 Russian Uniform
• 1 part 70.951 White

Alternative (Model Air):

• 71.016 US Dark Green
• Add 10â??15% White

---

Indian Red

Excellent formula:

• 5 parts 70.982 Cavalry Brown
• 2 parts 70.909 Vermilion
• 1 part 70.918 Ivory

For weathered structures:

Replace the Ivory with Buff.

---

Badger Modelflex

Bronze Green

• 85% Pullman Green
• 15% Reefer White

---

Indian Red

• 80% Oxide Red
• 15% Boxcar Red
• 5% Reefer White

---

Overall Rankings

Bronze Green

1. Vallejo (closest after slight lightening)
2. AK Interactive Real Colors
3. Mr. Color
4. Tamiya (mixed)
5. Mission Models
6. Badger Modelflex
7. Tru-Color
8. Micro-Mark

Indian Red

1. Vallejo Cavalry Brown mix
2. AK Interactive Oxide Red mix
3. Mr. Color mix
4. Tamiya Hull Red mix
5. Mission Models
6. Badger Modelflex
7. Tru-Color
8. Micro-Mark

A note about the Zephyr paint chips

From the uploaded chip sheet, the Bronze Green reproduction scans almost black, which is consistent with aged printed references and with the original prototype paint. For models, I would not match that chip literally. Instead, I'd lighten it by roughly 12â??15% while preserving its green hue. The Indian Red chip is closer to usable, but I'd increase its brightness slightly (about 5â??10%) to account for scale effect and the way small models absorb light.

If you're modeling CB&Q depots, section houses, towers, and freight houses from the 1940â??1968 era, these adjusted colors will generally produce a more convincing appearance than direct, full-strength matches to the printed chips.

 

 

 

Virus-free.www.avast.com

_._,_._,_

---

Groups.io Links:

You receive all messages sent to this group.

View/Reply Online (#68494) | Reply to Group | Reply to Sender | Mute This Topic | New Topic
Your Subscription | Contact Group Owner | Unsubscribe [archives@nauer.org]

_._,_._,_